Findings underscore the importance of assessing religious comfort in spirituality and health studies, but also support the current focus on spiritual struggles. Spiritual pain or distress can be normal feelings for someone who is living with illness. When trauma, spirituality, and mental illness intersect. Spiritual crisis and distress in an african american sample robert a. These missing cases are handled via listwise deletion, which accounts for nearly all of the 20% case loss 298 of the initial 1,445. Given the message that discomfort is unacceptable and that drugs and alcohol are ever present, it is little wonder that our children reach out for a chemical answer. Scholars have indeed linked disappointment with god and spiritual struggles to depressive symptoms and psychological distress ellison and lee 2010.
Rs struggles have been correlated with emotional distress and commonly manifest. Understanding and addressing religious and spiritual. Religiousspiritual rs struggles from a psychological perspective religiousspiritual rs struggles occur when some aspect of rs belief, practice or experience becomes a focus of negative thoughts or emotions, concern or conflict exline, 20. Consequently, the treatment profile is also diversified. Results are discussed in terms of their implications for future work linking religion, and particularly spiritual struggles, with health behaviors and outcomes. When using a spiritual coping framework, spiritual struggles may be conceptualized as originating in stressors that destabilize a persons spirituality, exacerbating the individuals distress over and above what the original stressor would have precipitated. On the other hand, greater rs conflicts with god or other people over faith predict greater psychological distress, particularly if spiritual struggles remain chronic and unresolved. Debakey veterans affairs medical center in houston, texas, conducted a study of 155 veterans examining the relationship between moral injury events, psychological distress, and religious spiritual struggles. Also consistent with our prediction, the relationship between spiritual struggles. This brief report examines the utility of a newly developed measure, the religious and spiritual struggles scale in gauging suicide risk in. Mindfulnessbased cognitive therapy for psychological. This brief report examines the utility of a newly developed measure, the religious and spiritual struggles scale in gauging suicide risk in veterans.
Bifactor models of religious and spiritual struggles. Religious and spiritual struggles are expressions of conflict, question, and doubt regarding matters of faith, god, and religious relationships. As predicted, the relationship between spiritual struggles and symptoms of psychological distress was stronger as reports of experiential avoidance increased. A growing body of research has linked these spiritual struggles to higher levels of psychological distress, declines in physical health and even greater risk of mortality. The present study assessed 96 doctoral psychology students at apaaccredited faithbased institutions to further understand the relationships between distress from clinical work, religious and spiritual rs struggles, and negative affect. In light of the fact that spiritual struggles are readily experienced by college students, albeit in varying intensities, what personal traits and attributes play a role in provoking them. These analyses demonstrate the discriminant validity of religious spiritual struggles and the complexity of their relationships with religiousness and distress. It seems that when depression leads people to struggle. Limited research has examined rs struggles among atheists, generally. The impact of spirituality on mental health mental health foundation.
Additionally, social support has been studied as one of the mechanisms through which religious attendance may yield a positive impact on physical and mental health 20 22. Struggles with ones rs beliefs andor practices may also contribute to elevated psychological distress. Positive coping strategy in islam linked with less depression, anxiety from spiritual struggles 14 august 2018 credit. Oct 30, 2018 more generally, the results of this study highlight the importance of religious coping for minority adults and the differential way positive and negative religious coping are associated with measures of psychological distress. Spiritual quest and aestheticallybased spiritual experience. Religious and spiritual rs struggles capture spiritual distress and are broadly defined as distress within rs domains exline, 20. Mindfulness meditation training for spiritual struggles. Mindfulnessbased cognitive therapy for japanese breast cancer patientsa. In contrast, in our previous observational study, we demonstrated that mbct yielded significant improvement in psychological distress, spiritual wellbeing, and qol in a sample of japanese patients with breast cancer. Dec 27, 2009 the issue of missing data deserves comment. Spirituality is a dynamic and intrinsic aspect of humanity through which persons seek ultimate meaning, purpose and transcendence, and experience relationship to self, family. Positive and negative religious coping as predictors of.
Thus, it is important for psychologists and other health care providers to be aware of the dual nature of religion and spirituality. Robust links between religiousspiritual struggles, psychological distress, and wellbeing in a national sample of american adults. These analyses demonstrate the discriminant validity of religiousspiritual struggles and the complexity of their relationships with religiousness and distress. A phenomenological analysis of college students spiritual. It is also important to point out that just as the psychological variable can be seen through the lens of shame, so too can our. To date, however, this literature has focused primarily on. Correspondingly, rs struggles are conceptualized as signs of spiritual disorientation, tension, and strain pargament, 2007, p. Meaning violations, religiousspiritual struggles, and meaning in life in the face of stressful life events judith e. A growing literature examines the correlates and sequelae of. Based on past research it was hypothesized that distress from clinical work would predict heightened rs struggles and.
To further develop a framework for understanding and treating the sequelae of pmie exposure, we examined the role of rs. Findings reveal strong and independent associations between each type of spiritual struggle and psychological distress, and they also show that these patterns. The correlates of spiritual struggle during the college years. Meaning violations, religiousspiritual struggles, and. Debakey veterans affairs medical center in houston, texas, conducted a study of 155 veterans examining the relationship between moral injury events, psychological distress, and religiousspiritual struggles. Struggles with ones rs beliefs and or practices may also contribute to elevated psychological distress. The effect of spirituality and religious attendance on the. These distress factors correlated with most of the independent group factors corresponding to the original dimensions of the rss, especially ultimate meaning and divine struggles. Pdf morally injurious events and psychological distress. Clinical depression consists of a group of disorders with various causes. Request pdf spiritual struggles and psychological distress. A critical issue involves identifying the religious factors that buffer this relationship. Particular attention has been focused on three specific types of such struggles. A growing literature examines the correlates and sequelae of spiritual struggles.
What are the unique spiritual and mental health consequences of the three different types of forgiveness i. Regarding the consequences of spiritual struggle, we found that struggling relates to lower levels of psychological wellbeing, physical health, and selfesteem. Certain forms of spiritual struggles can contribute to higher levels of distress, especially if god is viewed as being punitive, vengeful and withholding. Morally injurious events and psychological distress among veterans. Findings reveal strong and independent associations between each type of spiritual struggle and psychological distress, and they also show. More generally, the results of this study highlight the importance of religious coping for minority adults and the differential way positive and negative religious coping are associated with measures of psychological distress. Spiritual distress spiritual distress can be defined as the impaired ability to experience. What role do religion and spirituality play in mental health. Previous studies have established robust links between religious spiritual struggles rs struggles and poorer wellbeing and psychological distress.
They further added that there is a wide range of psychological distress, ranging from mild to extreme, with. This is the first study to empirically address this question. Religious and spiritual struggles rs struggles tension or conflicts regarding religious or spiritual mattershave been robustly linked to greater psychological distress and lower wellbeing. Spiritual beliefs are frequently important in medical decisions. Cc0 public domain adopting an islamic concept of coping with spiritual. Students in faithbased doctoral psychology programs. Coping with moral struggles arising from coronavirus stress. Abstract depression is one of the most pervasive disorders and a leading cause of disability worldwide. The spiritual aspects of dying are particularly challenging in that there is a lack of consensus on the definition of spirituality, who. Coping with moral struggles arising from coronavirus. Introduction to the special section on religion and. Briefly most missing values occur on items tapping spiritual struggles or other aspects of religious involvement, or on the measure of psychological distress. Spiritual struggles and suicide in veterans seeking ptsd.
Forgiveness and spiritual distress in an inpatient. This study examines the effects of negative interaction in church on psychological distress. Selfesteem, equanimity, psychological distress, and spiritual distress. This study is one of the first attempts to examine the relationships between religious and spiritual struggles rs struggles measured comprehensively and indicators of psychological distress i. Personal distress can increase when individuals use prayer as a form of. The values violated by pmies are often influenced by ones religionspirituality rs. However, little is known about the specific types of spiritual struggles that may confer risk. Theory, research, practice, and policy, 10, 360367. Limited research has examined rs struggles among atheists, generally conflating them. Spiritual struggles and mental health tweet phrases like spiritual struggle and experiential avoidance might not typically be heard in everyday conversation, but a short chat with bowling green state university psychology professor dr. Two other scales appeared to replicate domains that formed part of the framework we originally used to select the items. Religious spiritual rs struggles from a psychological perspective religious spiritual rs struggles occur when some aspect of rs belief, practice or experience becomes a focus of negative thoughts or emotions, concern or conflict exline, 20. After outlining a series of theoretical arguments linking negative interaction with health and wellbeing.
Religious and spiritual struggles rs strugglestension or conflicts regarding religious or spiritual mattershave been robustly linked to greater psychological distress and lower wellbeing. It may also confound the relationship between psychological distress and negative life events as it may be associated with both constructs 18, 19. Spiritual struggles and psychological distress baylor institute for. Spiritual distress an overview sciencedirect topics. Religious resources, spiritual struggles, and mental health in a nationwide sample of pcusa clergy. Spiritual distress most often occurs when a person is experiencing change, challenges, physical and emotional pain, other symptoms, and losses associated with serious illness.
Positive coping strategy in islam linked with less. Mirowsky and ross 1989 add that psychological distress is the unpleasant subjective state of depression and anxiety being tense, restless, worried irritable and afraid, which has both emotional and psychological manifestations. Most research in this area has relied on samples consisting predominantly of participants who believe in gods. Research also indicates that a subset of grievers struggles significantly and for a.
Spiritual struggles arise when practices that used to connect people with beauty lose their spiritual power. Pdf religious resources, spiritual struggles, and mental. Are religious comforts and strains associated with. Research indicates that trauma can precipitate a loss of faith and struggles in the spiritual domain, leading to increased suicide risk. Religious and spiritual struggles rs strugglestension or conflicts regarding religious or spiritual mattershave been robustly linked to greater psychological distress and. Request pdf robust links between religious spiritual struggles, psychological distress, and wellbeing in a national sample of american adults this study is one of the first attempts to. Terminally ill patients are often confronted with severe existential symptoms and spiritual distress that can challenge health care providers. In other words, it is psychological discomfort that interferes with. What are the dimensions of forgiveness and spiritual distress among psychiatric inpatients. Examining the mediating role of religious and spiritual struggles. Understanding the relationship between spiritual struggles and. Jackson, in evidencebased practice in palliative medicine, 20.
148 64 826 544 1289 676 546 1219 664 155 355 1359 560 491 44 626 752 400 1138 154 920 799 574 598 1128 744 846 652 1400 160 456 786 1278 781 1188 423 311 111 1089 985 121 965 565 24 292 1079